Voices
from the street:
CRB highlights issues affecting homeless youth in
California
The
California Research Bureau (CRB) has been
conducting a research and policy education project
on homeless youth for almost 2 years now. The
project, funded by The California Wellness
Foundation, has brought together a diverse group
of researchers, program directors, local and state
agency program managers, local and state
policymakers, and homeless and formerly homeless
youth to identify and discuss the many challenges
facing homeless young people. The CRB project team
consists of Ginny Puddefoot (Project Director) and
Lisa Foster (Senior Researcher for the project),
under the direction of Charlene Simmons (Assistant
Director). CRB once again partnered with
independent journalist Nell Bernstein and the
California Council on Youth Relations (CCYR),
which greatly expanded the project team’s
capacity to reach community-based providers and
homeless and formerly homeless youth.
Surveying
street youth: the heart of the research
Perhaps
the most unique aspect of this project is that the
research included a street-outreach survey in
which homeless and formerly homeless youth were
recruited and trained to interview their peers
throughout the state. Over 200 interviews were
conducted in 23 cities in California. In addition,
CCYR organized focus groups of homeless youth in
several cities. This research is at the heart of
the recently-released CRB report, “Voices
from the Street: A Survey of Homeless Youth by
Their Peers”. The report summarizes the
research findings about homeless youth’s
experiences, their ideas about the kind of support
that would help them the most, and the changes
they would like to see happen in policy or law.
The
research findings clearly debunk many
misconceptions about homeless youth being willing
runaways seeking freedom from parental control and
social responsibility on the street. Among the
most compelling research findings are the
following:
- Many
homeless youth do not identify themselves—or
even consider themselves—“homeless”.
Rather, they see themselves as staying in a
variety of “unstable”
situations—couch-surfing one night, staying
at a homeless shelter for a night or two,
sleeping in a car, camping out, even
occasionally staying in a hotel with other
homeless youth. Defining “homeless” as
lacking a stable or permanent living situation
encompasses these varied circumstances.
- Young
people between the ages of 12 and 25 who are
on their own have been almost completely
overlooked by federal, state and local
policies and programs on homelessness. Public
programs focus primarily on two specific
populations: homeless families and chronically
homeless adults. Yet the population of
homeless youth in the US is estimated at
between 5 and 8 percent of the total youth in
that age group—about 1 to 1.6 million young
people under the age of 18 experience
homelessness each year.
- Almost
all the homeless young people interviewed for
this project want to find stable housing, get
an education, find work, and get off the
street. They know their chances of maintaining
a job or returning to school while they are
homeless are slim.
- The
vast majority did not become homeless by
choice; they were pushed into it either
because their parents (including foster
parents) explicitly kicked them out or because
of abuse or conflict in the family. Many young
people interviewed expressed the wish that
some kind of family support or counseling
could have been provided before they were
forced to leave home.
- Almost
half of the homeless youth surveyed felt safer
on the street than they had at home because of
the violence, drug use, or sexual abuse they
were subjected to at home. This is an
important reason that many of these young
people remain hidden—they do not want to be
forced to return to an unsafe home. Yet many
of them maintain some contact with family
members even while they are living on the
street.
- In
the last few years, there has been growing
recognition of the difficulties faced by one
subset of homeless youth: those who emancipate
from foster care. State funding has
appropriately been made available to provide
some supports and services to these youth. Yet
while an estimated 25% to 40% of homeless
youth emancipated from foster care, the
majority of homeless youth were missed by the
child welfare system and so are not eligible
for the existing public supports and services.
Informing
policymakers: lunch-time seminars draw capacity
crowds
The
second phase of the project was a series of six
policy seminars, each focusing on a different
issue facing homeless youth. These issues include
a lack of shelter and educational opportunities,
health and mental health needs, and problematic
interaction with law enforcement agencies and the
courts. Two of the seminars were convened by
legislators, one of whom was moved by what he
heard to introduce legislation to require the
state to engage in a strategic planning process
for addressing the needs of homeless youth in
California (SB 1470/465, Lowenthal). Overall, over
400 legislative staff, state department and agency
staff, and others involved in state policy
attended one or more of the seminars.
Again,
perhaps the most unique aspect of the seminars is
that homeless and formerly homeless youth were
actively involved in the discussions—after much
careful preparation to be sure the experience
would be positive for them. (See the CRB report by
Lisa Foster, Preparing Youth to Participate in
State Policymaking, for more information about
this.) Each young person who participated in the
seminars came with an adult mentor, someone they
knew and trusted, and each received a stipend for
their participation.
Many
participants in the seminars expressed deep
appreciation for what they learned, and for the
remarks by young people. A number wrote that they
had never really thought about homeless youth
before and had assumed all street kids were
runaways and there by choice. In response to the
question “How did attending the seminar
influence your thinking about homeless youth in
California?”, one participant wrote: “I gained
a deeper understanding of the issue, realized that
we are grossly underestimating the severity of the
situation; began to explore ways my agency can
possibly outreach to and engage homeless youth.”
Another wrote: “I realize we should not give up
on them, that they do want help, but that we need
a system that is inclusive and accessible. They
are smart and full of dreams, just like other
youth.”
In
conjunction with the policy seminars, CRB released
two additional reports. Patricia Julianelle, JD, a
nationally-recognized expert on educational issues
and homeless youth, authored the CRB report, The
Educational Success of Homeless Youth in
California: Challenges and Solutions, which
summarizes education requirements and issues, and
identifies successful educational program models.
In addition, Lisa Foster and a team of interns
compiled resources on an ongoing basis that were
periodically published in an annotated
bibliography. The final product will soon be
published as a CRB report, Homeless Youth:
Bibliography and Resources.
Next
steps
The
final component of the project is currently in
development: a DVD is being produced by CCYR and
youth media that will include highlights from the
research and seminars as well as homeless and
formerly homeless youth’s recommendations for
policy change. This DVD will be distributed widely
to state policymakers and others interested in
addressing the challenges facing homeless youth.
Thanks
to a renewed 3-year $240,000 grant from the
California Wellness Foundation effective the end
of July 2008, the CRB project team will further
deepen policymakers’ understanding of specific
barriers facing homeless youth and explore
innovative approaches to preventing youth
homelessness and assisting youth who are already
on the street.
For
more information about this project, please
contact Ginny Puddefoot or Lisa Foster at the CRB
at (916) 653-7843.
|